clause |
topic |
amend # |
source |
advice |
comment |
REJECTION |
Reject the directive outright |
47 |
Greens; GUE; |
+ |
Balanced question, but better to think again |
ARTICLES |
|
|
|
|
|
A1.1 |
subject matter and scope |
19 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
69 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A1.2 |
|
20 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A2.2a |
data |
21 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A2.2ba |
serious crim. offense |
22 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
telephone service |
70 |
EPP+PSE |
- |
|
A2.2bb |
unsuccessful call |
23 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
user ID |
71 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A2.2bc |
cell ID |
72 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A2.2bd |
unsuccessful call attempt |
73 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A3a |
access to retained data |
27 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
76 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A3b |
Data protect. & security |
28 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A3.1 |
ref. Directive 2002/58/EC |
24 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
74 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A3.2 |
only provided to the competent national authorities |
25 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
unsuccessful call attempt |
75 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A3.2a |
list of competent authorities |
26 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A4 |
types of data to be retained |
29 and 31 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
30 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
77 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A4.2a |
no content retention |
78 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A5 |
revision of the annex |
32=79 |
LIBE / EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A6 |
Committee 1 |
33=80 |
LIBE / EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A7 |
period of retention |
34 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
81 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A7a |
data security principles |
82 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A7.1a |
EP duly informed |
35 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A8 |
transmission to authorities |
36 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
83 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A8a |
Sanctions |
38 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
Supervisory authority |
84 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A8.1a |
contact point |
37 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A9a |
Supervisory authorities |
40 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A9.1 |
statistics yearly sent to CEC |
39 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A10 |
reimbursement |
41=93 |
LIBE / Cederschiold |
++ |
|
|
deleted |
85 |
EPP+PSE |
-- |
|
A11 |
ref. Directive 2002/58/EC |
42 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
86 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A11a |
Future measures |
87 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A11b |
Remedies, liability sanctions |
88 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A12.1 |
eval. necessity, effectiveness |
43 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
application & impact study |
89 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A12.2 |
examine all observations |
44 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
A13.1.1 |
period for adoption |
90 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A13.2a |
extra deferral on internet data |
91 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
A14a |
Revision |
45 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|||||
RECITALS |
|
|
|
|
|
R3 |
ref 2002/58/EC |
1 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R4 |
scope of the rights and obligations |
2 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R4a |
respect for private life |
3 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R6 |
types of data and ret. period |
4 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R6a |
better and more equal access to justice and appeal |
5 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R7 |
deleted |
6=51 |
LIBE / EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R8 |
data ret. may be a valuable tool |
7 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R9a |
rivate life and correspondence |
52 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R10 |
need to adopt common measures |
8 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
53 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R10a |
tasks laid down in Article 30 95/46/EC |
9 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R11 |
need to ensure harmonised period of time |
10 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
|
54 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R11a |
balance agains invasion of privacy |
11 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
R12 |
periodic review of such provisions |
12 |
LIBE |
0 |
|
|
deleted |
55 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R12a |
2002/58/EC apply other than that covered by this Directive |
56 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R13 |
does not relate to data that is the content |
57 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R14 |
haring of experience of best practice |
58 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R15a |
concerning measures to ensure data quality |
59 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R16 |
data ret. only provided to the competent national authorities |
60 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R16a |
sanction infringements of the provisions |
61 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R16b |
unlawful processing operation |
62 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R17 |
deleted |
13=63 |
LIBE / EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R17a |
Convention on Cybercrime & for the Protection of Individuals |
64 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R18 |
it is unclear whether this Directive does not go beyond what is necessary and proportionate |
14 |
LIBE |
++ |
|
|
this Directive does not go beyond what is necessary |
65 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R18a |
highest standards of data storage security |
15 |
LIBE |
+ |
|
R18b |
security of data |
16 |
LIBE |
+ |
|
R19 |
This Directive could better respect the fundamental rights and the principles recognised |
17 |
LIBE |
++ |
|
R19a |
implementation takes place following consultations with the business sector, particularly as regards feasibility and cost of retention |
18 |
LIBE |
++ |
|
|
not intended to harmonise the technology |
66 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R19b |
tables that illustrate the correlation between directives and the transposition |
67 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
R19c |
Member States to adopt legislative measure concerning the right of access to and use of data |
68 |
EPP+PSE |
0 |
|
